It’s time we had a word with Big Pencil and their buddy Big Eraser

I looked in every desk jar, searched every junk drawer, checked the supply closet, and yet I could only find one, old, yellow, Dixon No 2 pencil with no eraser. Not just no eraser: the eraser has been rubbed completely flat. Even the edges of the ferrule has been dented by someone trying to get that one last bit of rubber off the crown. As I sat there looking at this barely half-useful object I wondered why? It’s still 16cm long. This pencil has a lot of life left in it. Why are pencils five times longer than the useful life of their erasers? Why are our only choices to either throw away a pencil when the eraser dies, go out and buy “eraser caps”, or hold on to the eraserless pencil like a sexless marriage?

The average pre-sharpened pencil is 19mm and the average pencil size when the eraser wears out is 16mm. You get two, maybe three, tops four, sharpens out of one pencil before it loses its eraser and you have to resort to crossing out mistakes.

Crossing out? Are you fucking kidding me? Is this the dark ages? Am I smearing shit on a cave wall? I buy pencils because they can be erased. Holy fucking shit. No, ding dong, I want a pencil with an eraser.

Oh man, and don’t start in on eraser caps. Those are great. IF YOU LIKE TO HAVE SOMETHING FLY OFF THE CROWN OF YOUR PENCIL WHILE YOU ARE ERASING SOMETHING AND THEN YOU TEAR YOUR PAPER WITH THE FERRULE LIKE THE CLAWS OF A HARPY RIPPING THROUGH A SAILOR’S CHEST ON HIS QUEST FOR THE GOLDEN FLEECE.

Oh, wait, or.. you could just carry around another eraser. That’s great isn’t it? You get to carry around a second object just so that you can do the work that one object should be able to do on its own. An eraser. And you know what an eraser necessitates? Yeah, a fucking pencil case. Announce your impotence to the world by showing up somewhere with a pencil case and whipping out an eraserless pencil and a big ole eraser.

Or if you’re less organized, you get to run around the house like King Lear in the storm searching for both the pencil and the lodestone eraser. “I am a man more sinned against than sinning!” I shout as I search high and low for my two-tool implement.

And which type of eraser should you get, huh? Those pink ones? We all remember those beauties. Remember how they would SMEAR THE WRITING ALL OVER THE PAGE? Then you would rub it on your jeans to get some of your finger grease off it so that it would erase again and then it would leave a pink streak on your paper. By the time you were done writing and erasing, your test paper looked like Cy Twombly’s, Leda and the Swan.

And if you had one of those pink erasers for more than a few weeks, it would dry up and crumble when you tried to use it like Hela crushing Mjölnir. I have so many fond memories of how we had to sometimes rub the little eraser rubble on the page because our decrepit old eraser was falling apart.

And hey, look, there are times when having a special eraser and a pencil make sense. If you’re an artist or something, sure. Get you a Faber-Castle pencil with a bald crown and an elephant ear eraser. But I’m not Leonardo da Vinci over here. I’m using a pencil to write down stupid notes like “write a blog post about pencils” or “get more bread flower flour.” I don’t need to be held hostage to Big Pencil and Big Eraser’s two-object tyranny.

No friends, Big Pencil has a lot to answer for. My choices are to buy a pencil that’s way too long and throw it away when its eraser dies, wasting a bunch of useful pencil and pinging my liberal guilt, or hang on to these half-useful objects like some kind of pencil hoarder and buy eraser caps or big clunky erasers. The only sensible conclusion here is that Big Pencil and Big Eraser are in cahoots to get us to buy more pencils and erasers.

Oh and fuck your mechanical pencils. I don’t need to bring 3 objects, mini erasers, lead that snaps constantly, and Elon Musk level terrible engineering into something simple and perfect like a pencil.

Wood, graphite, and eraser. That’s all I ask for.

Qq

Post Script: the writer went to Fred Meyer and purchased 10 “eco friendly” Dixon, Ticonderoga (all rights reserved) pencils with big, knobby erasers.

36 comments

  1. Simple solution. Before putting pencil to paper (literally), simply (1) perfectly form your thoughts prior to writing anything down and then (2) carefully right those perfectly formed thoughts down, not making any mistakes. No distractions, no Euro matches on in the background, etc. Guaranteed to work. You are welcome.

    1. Also make sure that your hand doesn’t have one of those brain-to-hand moments where you try to write an ‘a’ but it comes out like ~~~)

  2. “… or hold on to the eraserless pencil like a sexless marriage?”

    I’m dead. 😂😂😂

  3. “No friends, Big Pencil has a lot to answer for.” nicely done.

    i’m a pencil snob. with all of the math associated with chemistry and physics, i abandoned pens quite a while ago. i also used to rewrite my class notes due to poor handwriting. i’m a mechanical pencil guy, specifically dr. grip by pilot. they allow you to replace not only leads but erasers. however, my favorite is one i jacked from my 8-year old daughters crayon box back in the day. it was one of those fat red pencils kids use in kindergarten when they’re first learning how to write. the leads are like 1.5mm and the only thing lasting longer than those erasers are the cockroach. she still had one so i assumed ownership. don’t judge me; she was a 3rd grader and wasn’t gonna use it anymore.

    1. These are all valid points which I will raise with the author.

      By the way, there are fat pencils at Fred Meyer right now, labeled as “my first pencil”, and they come with their own special sharpener. I thought about getting one. Now, I think I will!

  4. Ahh, glimmer of recognition. The eraser that someone tried to use beyond the limits of its metal ring, and now it’s more black than white.

    Im old enough to remember when you had to have the right kind of pencil to legibly answer SAT questions. Still love pencils. And notebooks to scrawl in, for that matter.

    I plan to build a house soon, 2 levels, and Ive been working my pencil hard over the many revisions. I use a lined notebook, with each space denoting 5 feet, but I’ll have to get an exercise book with squares. Approximating the horizontal distances doesnt make for precision.

  5. You, dear Tim, need to read some Nicholson Baker. The Mezzanine, his first, and most singularly obsessed with the minutiae, is his best.

  6. Pencils
    PENCILS
    telling where the wind comes from
    open a story.

    Pencils
    telling where the wind goes
    end a story.

    These eager pencils
    come to a stop
    .. only .. when the stars high over
    come to a stop.

    Out of cabalistic to-morrows
    come cryptic babies calling life
    a strong and a lovely thing.
    I have seen neither these
    nor the stars high over
    come to a stop.
    Neither these nor the sea horses
    running with the clocks of the moon.
    Nor even a shooting star
    snatching a pencil of fire
    writing a curve of gold and white.
    Like you .. I counted the shooting stars of a winter
    night and my head was dizzy with all
    of them calling one by one:

    Look for us again.

    – Carl Sandburg

    1. I’ve always loved “Pencils” by Carl Sandburg and I thought I must share with those who’ve never read it. It’s a #2 HB in the world of poetry. Sorry, no eraser

  7. gregdraws.co.uk for some serious pencil action motherfunsters, you’re welcome

    1. Greg– that’s brilliant work my friend.
      I’m going to send the link to my better half. We may be in touch.

    2. i agree with jw1. lovely work my friend. maybe we can help you make some money.

      1. Thanks guys, just starting up the business and the site’s not even finished yet but any sharing of the link would be welcome!

  8. Another awesome post Tim. You are a fantastic writer. Keep it coming. Whenever I think of writers and pencils and writers struggles I actually think of one the great Pete Townshend’s songs “Guitar and Pen”. Even though he uses the word pen rather then pencil because it works better with the lyrics and he is talking about writing a song it captures the frustration I think a lot of writers must feel when they are working.

  9. In the UK when I was growing up erasers were known as rubbers, which of course have a completely different meaning over here. If you re-read this article substituting “rubber” for “eraser”, it brings a whole new meaning to the concept of “Big Pencil”…

    1. Are you suggesting discarding the rubber after each time you use your Big pencil?
      And what do you do when you need to put some lead in it?

  10. Early in a career as a designer– I started out as a draftsman. Or, thought I wanted to be one. This was pre-CAD. The training course required the use of hand-sharpened pencils (using a little spinning device, attached to the right side of the drafting table). No mechanicals like the pros used. To allow for another draftsman to pickup where one left off– every drawing was to be started left-to-right. Which is pretty effed-up for a lefty. This was like Purgatory. If you thought lefties wrote with their arms in strange positions in a classroom (cause the desks were made for righties)– watching someone lefthanded contort to draw lead-on-mylar and smudge-free was darkly comical. Finished that training course with hopes I’d be promoted– but alas.

    Years later, caught a break. Went to work for a buddy in his graphic design studio. As a gofer for two younger, very talented artists. Still in the era– where everything was pasted up to art boards by hand and photographed to make negatives for printing presses. Had no idea how I would ever advance in the field. Two years on PCs became available to consumers. Had access to one through a friend that was loaded with professional design software.

    Spent the next 2 decades making my living as a graphic and web designer. With an ability to create anything I could imagine with almost any software.

    As long as there was an ‘Undo’ button. 😁

    1. I feel like such an old man sometimes, I’m paper and pencil all the way and I think anyone who’s mastered the digital arts is very cool and impressive and should probably get off my lawn

      1. You have a gifted hand my friend. Your rendering of the iconic young Cassius Clay photo is just splendid! Ali is a lifelong personal hero.

        Was all about pen and ink when I was younger. Toted a spiral drawing book and fine point pen for years. Much as I enjoyed the creativity of designing digitally– it eventually became work. Still produce for a trio of freelance clients I’ve worked with since the early-90s. But eight or 9 years back I flipped from right-brained to left– shapeshifting into an IT guy.

        Every few months– I get a call from one of those clients– and jump into The Wayback Machine…

  11. When I got to “Dixon No 2” I thought you were gonna segue to something Lee Dixon said or did, seeing as his Arsenal shirt number was 2. Heh

Comments are closed.

Related articles